I found Winnemuca's reading from Life Among the Paiutes to be very telling about the true meaning of the "Savage" stereotype placed upon the Native Americans. Through her writing I believe that Winnemuca really transforms her readers image of the indigenous people away from an aggressive monstrous image to friendly and peaceful, I know it did for me at least.
By talking through the personal experiences of her tribe and specifically her and her families experiences with the white really captures the reader to empathize with the indigenous viewpoint. After reading about the grandfather and chief leader continuously trying to welcome the whites with a friendly greeting and the amount of excitement her grandfather elicited about the arrival of the whites, it allowed their true intentions to shine through. The Native Americans had no intentions of doing anything but aid the whites upon their arrival, offering aid with food and housing helping them survive on unfamiliar land. To me, this made the poor treatment of the indigenous people to be even more devastating, for their pure intentions were met with nothing but greed and cruelty.
The power of women's autobiography is often underestimated by historians, but as you point out, there is something incredibly powerful about the testimony of a single person. It accounts for more than just numbers and facts, and it shows people living their lives versus being represented as something that is static or easily reduced to statistics.
ReplyDelete